Guillermo del Toro: “I’d Rather Die” Than Use AI

Guillermo del Toro, the acclaimed director known for his distinctive cinematic vision, has unequivocally expressed his strong opposition to the use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) in his filmmaking. In a recent statement that has resonated throughout the industry, del Toro declared he would “rather die” than integrate such technology into his creative process, underlining a firm commitment to human artistry and traditional craftsmanship.

Guillermo del Toro’s Unwavering Stance on Generative AI

The director of visually rich and emotionally complex films like “Pan’s Labyrinth” and “The Shape of Water” made his position clear, stating, “AI, particularly generative AI — I am not interested, nor will I ever be interested.” He further emphasized his conviction, hoping to “be able to remain uninterested in using it at all until I croak.” This resolute declaration highlights a deep-seated belief against the encroachment of AI into the artistic realm, particularly concerning the generation of creative content.

Del Toro’s stance reflects a broader conversation within Hollywood and the creative industries about the ethical implications and artistic integrity surrounding AI tools. His rejection is not merely a preference but a profound philosophical position on the future of storytelling and the role of human creators.

Connecting AI to “Natural Stupidity” and Frankenstein’s Arrogance

Expanding on his strong views, del Toro posited that the inherent danger lies not necessarily in the technology of AI itself, but in what he termed “natural stupidity” – the human propensity for mishandling powerful tools without considering the full ramifications. He believes this “natural stupidity” fuels many of the world’s most detrimental characteristics.

Drawing a poignant parallel to one of his iconic themes, del Toro connected the arrogance of AI developers to Victor Frankenstein, the titular character of Mary Shelley’s novel. He noted that Frankenstein’s “arrogance” and his act of “creating something without considering the consequences” mirror the blind ambition sometimes observed in the tech world. This connection is particularly relevant as del Toro is adapting “Frankenstein” for Netflix, featuring a cast including Jacob Elordi, Oscar Isaac, Mia Goth, Christoph Waltz, and Ralph Ineson, with a release anticipated on November 7th.

A Broader Industry Discussion on AI in Filmmaking

Guillermo del Toro’s outspoken views contribute to a vigorous ongoing debate within the entertainment industry regarding artificial intelligence. Many artists, writers, and directors share concerns about AI’s potential impact on originality, intellectual property, and job security. The ability of generative AI to create images, scripts, and even entire digital characters raises questions about authorship, ethical sourcing of training data, and the intrinsic value of human creativity. Del Toro’s firm position serves as a powerful voice advocating for the preservation of human-centric artistic processes amidst technological advancements.

Prioritizing Human Craft and Artistic Integrity

Del Toro’s filmmaking is characterized by a meticulous attention to detail, intricate practical effects, and a deeply personal touch that imbues his fantastical worlds with tangible emotion. His preference for handcrafted elements and the nuanced work of human artists is a hallmark of his style. This commitment to traditional methods and the profound impact of human imagination stands in stark contrast to the automated processes of generative AI. His declaration underscores a belief that true artistic expression requires human intuition, empathy, and the unique imperfections that define genuine craftsmanship.

Conclusion

Guillermo del Toro’s resolute declaration against employing generative AI in his films is more than just a personal choice; it’s a powerful statement on the importance of human creativity and artistic integrity in an increasingly technology-driven world. By comparing unchecked AI development to the hubris of Victor Frankenstein, del Toro urges a pause for reflection on the ethical and artistic implications of such advancements. His commitment to traditional filmmaking methods ensures that his future works will continue to be products of singular human vision, reinforcing the irreplaceable value of the human hand and mind in storytelling.